Leading rookies in Wisconsin in 2023, ranked by total volume. Powered by ChatMMI — the only fully conversational AI experience for mortgage and real estate data.
As of May 28, 2026, the top 3 include John Olla (Cream City Mortgage, LLC, NMLS #2448240), Meghan Mueller (Capital Credit Union, NMLS #2469211), and Tyler Schmidt (Compeer Financial, ACA, NMLS #2478237).
Updated · Recorded mortgage transactions typically appear in this dataset approximately 22 days after the recording date.
| Rank | Loan officer | LO NMLS | Current Lender / Broker | Lender NMLS | Location | 2023 Volume | 2023 Loans | Avg Loan |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| #1 | John Olla | 2448240 | Cream City Mortgage, LLC | 2439594 | Whitefish Bay, WI | $6.3M | 18 | $349K |
| #2 | Meghan Mueller | 2469211 | Capital Credit Union | 442983 | — | $2.9M | 32 | $89K |
| #3 | Tyler Schmidt | 2478237 | Compeer Financial, ACA | 619731 | Baldwin, WI | $2.7M | 15 | $183K |
| #4 | Robert Bastien | 2481936 | FIRST COMMUNITY BANK | 803624 | Milton, WI | $1.2M | 5 | $242K |
| #5 | David Mo | 2508877 | Epic Mortgage Processing LLC | 2404936 | Hampshire, IL | $1.0M | 10 | $104K |
| #6 | Clifford Amundson | 2443959 | Union Home Mortgage Corp. | 2229 | Onalaska, WI | $941K | 4 | $235K |
| #7 | Morgan Franks | 2495373 | Union Home Mortgage Corp. | 2229 | Eau Claire, WI | $910K | 5 | $182K |
| #8 | Courtney Gibson | 2477083 | CFR Mortgage LLC | 2474471 | — | $837K | 3 | $279K |
| #9 | Alexa Franck | 2371980 | Edge Home Finance, LLC | 891464 | Minnetonka, MN | $825K | 2 | $413K |
| #10 | Alexis Boston | 2458983 | First Citizens State Bank | 460941 | Whitewater, WI | $756K | 3 | $252K |
| #11 | Samuel Aleknavicius | 2414079 | Secure Choice Lending | 1689518 | De Pere, WI | $677K | 3 | $226K |
| #12 | Jeremy Kottman | 2424814 | Community First Credit Union | 451378 | — | $622K | 6 | $104K |
| #13 | Deborah Stiemke | 2460153 | WESTBY CO-OP CREDIT UNION | 486034 | — | $594K | 6 | $99K |
| #14 | Kellen Nowack | 2426251 | Mortgage Research Center, LLC | 1907 | Earth City, MO | $574K | 2 | $287K |
| #15 | Hans Schneiker | 2418035 | Epic Mortgage Processing LLC | 2404936 | — | $574K | 3 | $191K |
| #16 | Matthew Piccari | 2404828 | PennyMac Loan Services, LLC | 35953 | Pasadena, CA | $561K | 2 | $280K |
| #17 | Dakota Watton | 2514287 | Citizens State Bank of Loyal | 402918 | Neillsville, WI | $554K | 7 | $79K |
| #18 | Mustafa Qassim | 1734707 | Lendify Home Loans LLC | 2602334 | Troy, MI | $532K | 2 | $266K |
| #19 | Bryce Arend | 2447168 | Fairway Independent Mortgage Corporation | 2289 | — | $507K | 3 | $169K |
| #20 | Allyson Stanley | 2539537 | Landmark Credit Union | 401043 | Brookfield, WI | $490K | 3 | $163K |
| #21 | Shelly Storm | 2504123 | CROSSBRIDGE COMMUNITY BANK | 402921 | Tomahawk, WI | $483K | 3 | $161K |
| #22 | Nicholas Cicotte | 1510088 | PennyMac Loan Services, LLC | 35953 | Franklin, TN | $455K | 3 | $152K |
| #23 | Burhan Yaish | 2443132 | United Mortgage Lending LLC | 2220134 | Troy, MI | $454K | 1 | $454K |
| #24 | John Whitehead | 2447998 | Bank CMG | 491916 | Brookfield, WI | $436K | 2 | $218K |
| #25 | Kaden McClain | 2463429 | Gold Star Mortgage Financial Group, Corporation | 3446 | — | $410K | 3 | $137K |
| #26 | Kevin Kim | 2503377 | Texana Bank, N.A. | 407536 | — | $409K | 2 | $204K |
| #27 | Matthew Honzik | 2487861 | HOLY FAMILY MEMORIAL CREDIT UNION | 409303 | — | $406K | 4 | $101K |
| #28 | AMANDA SUGDEN | 671612 | Rocket Mortgage, LLC | 3030 | — | $399K | 2 | $199K |
| #29 | Tara Appleton | 738203 | Lutheran Church Extension Fund-Missouri Synod | 3444 | Saint Louis, MO | $384K | 1 | $384K |
| #30 | Jaylen Shelton | 2462825 | Capital One, National Association | 453156 | — | $384K | 4 | $96K |
| #31 | Izaz Ahmed | 2415774 | American Pacific Mortgage Corporation | 1850 | Dallas, TX | $362K | 1 | $362K |
| #32 | William Ciraldo | 2440601 | U.S. Bank National Association | 402761 | Cuyahoga Falls, OH | $346K | 1 | $346K |
| #33 | Beth Kazinski | 2464164 | Waukesha State Bank | 439834 | — | $345K | 3 | $115K |
| #34 | Vesna Stimac | 2481344 | Discover Bank | 684042 | — | $344K | 2 | $172K |
| #35 | Madison Hellickson | 2336375 | NEXA Mortgage, LLC | 1660690 | Sumner, WA | $336K | 1 | $336K |
| #36 | Gian Morales-Martinez | 2514460 | PARK BANK, THE | 477718 | Fitchburg, WI | $328K | 1 | $328K |
| #37 | Adam Mercado | 2094508 | ClearPath Lending | 936436 | Irvine, CA | $321K | 1 | $321K |
| #38 | Olivia Olson | 2452971 | American Pacific Mortgage Corporation | 1850 | — | $320K | 1 | $320K |
| #39 | MARYELLA PORRAS | 2522666 | Luminate Bank | 1281698 | De Pere, WI | $317K | 2 | $159K |
| #40 | Alma Tapia Lopez | 2485461 | Barrett Financial Group, L.L.C. | 181106 | Chandler, AZ | $299K | 1 | $299K |
| #41 | Noah Twomey | 2471192 | Fairway Independent Mortgage Corporation | 2289 | — | $292K | 3 | $97K |
| #42 | Lori Stephens | 2449340 | Homestead Mortgage LLC | 1934348 | — | $267K | 1 | $267K |
| #43 | Robert Heinrich | 2463354 | NATIONS LENDING CORPORATION | 32416 | Independence, OH | $267K | 2 | $133K |
| #44 | Samuel Elmaani | 2479018 | New Day Financial, LLC | 1043 | West Palm Beach, FL | $266K | 1 | $266K |
| #45 | Vanessa Meyers | 2452468 | New American Funding, LLC | 6606 | Columbia, MO | $255K | 1 | $255K |
| #46 | Justin Harford | 2525420 | Plains Commerce Bank | 463950 | — | $250K | 1 | $250K |
| #47 | Loren Brewer | 2481343 | Discover Bank | 684042 | — | $245K | 3 | $82K |
| #48 | Christopher Childs | 2507532 | Amerisave Mortgage Corporation | 1168 | Sandy Springs, GA | $243K | 1 | $243K |
| #49 | Johnathan Joy | 2461587 | Texana Bank, N.A. | 407536 | — | $235K | 1 | $235K |
| #50 | Frank Garay | 2477104 | ProLending Mortgage, LLC | 262563 | Webster, TX | $230K | 1 | $230K |
These rankings are powered by MMI's nationwide residential mortgage public record dataset. MMI collects mortgage transaction data from recording jurisdictions across the United States, with an average data latency of approximately 22 days from the recording date.
Transactions are matched to NMLS identifiers for loan officers, lenders, and brokers where applicable. MMI then deduplicates, normalizes, and validates this data to create an authoritative mortgage production dataset that powers MMI's analytics, recruiting, marketing, and intelligence products.
Rankings reflect recorded mortgage transactions available to MMI at the time of the last data refresh. Recent activity may continue to update as additional transactions are recorded and processed.
TopMortgageOriginators.com. Leading Rookies by Volume — Wisconsin (2023). Powered by MMI public record mortgage production data, accessed May 28, 2026. https://topmortgageoriginators.com/lo-leaderboard/wisconsin/top-rookie-by-volume/2023
Powered by ChatMMI